If you are searching for the best pizza in McCall, Idaho, this guide highlights the top local restaurants you need to try. Known for its mountain scenery, Payette Lake, and year-round outdoor recreation, McCall is also home to a surprisingly strong food scene. After a day skiing, hiking, or spending time on the lake, pizza is one of the most satisfying and convenient dining options.
This guide is designed for visitors staying in McCall, Donnelly, and the surrounding Long Valley area, including guests of Casago Long Valley and Treasure Valley properties. Below, you will find the top pizza restaurants, complete with menu links, locations, and what to expect.
Hometown Pizza
Menu: https://www.hometownpizzamccall.com/menu
Address: 337 Deinhard Ln, McCall, ID 83638
Hometown Pizza is one of the most well-known and consistently recommended pizza spots in McCall. They are known for their house-made dough, flavorful sauce, and a wide variety of specialty pizzas. The atmosphere is casual and family-friendly, making it a great choice for groups, families, or a relaxed night out.
This is also a strong option for takeout if you are heading back to your vacation rental after a long day outdoors.
Toll Station Pizza
Menu: https://tollstationpizza.com/
Address: 410 Railroad Ave, McCall, ID 83638
Located in downtown McCall, Toll Station Pizza has been a local staple for decades. The menu goes beyond pizza, offering pasta, sandwiches, and a full bar, which makes it a good option for groups with different tastes.
The space is large and welcoming, and it is a convenient stop if you are already exploring downtown or spending time near Payette Lake.
Growler’s Pizza & Grill
Menu: https://growlerspizza.com/menu/
Address: 501 N 3rd St, McCall, ID 83638
Growler’s Pizza and Grill offers a broader menu that includes pizza, burgers, sandwiches, and comfort food favorites. It is a good option if your group is not set on pizza alone.
With a casual atmosphere and a variety of menu items, it works well for families or groups looking for something easy and flexible.
Crusty’s Pizza
Menu: https://places.singleplatform.com/crustys-pizza-10/menu
Address: 214 Lenora St, McCall, ID 83638
Crusty’s Pizza is a reliable go-to for classic and specialty pizzas. The menu includes everything from traditional combinations to more unique options, making it easy to find something for everyone.
It is especially popular for a laid-back dinner after a full day of outdoor activities and is known for consistently solid quality.
Salmon River Brewery
Menu: https://www.toasttab.com/local/order/salmon-river-brewery
Address: 411 Railroad Ave, McCall, ID 83638
While primarily known as a brewery, Salmon River Brewery also serves pizza along with a full food menu. This makes it a great option if you want to pair your meal with locally brewed beer.
The location near downtown and the lake, along with indoor and outdoor seating options, make it one of the more versatile dining experiences in McCall.
Where to Get Pizza in McCall, Idaho
McCall may be a smaller destination, but it offers a range of pizza options that fit different needs, whether you are dining in, grabbing takeout, or feeding a group at your vacation rental.
For guests staying with Casago in Long Valley or Treasure Valley, these restaurants are all convenient options that provide reliable, high-quality meals after a day of exploring the area.
Be sure to check menus ahead of time, especially during peak travel seasons, and consider takeout for a more relaxed evening in your rental.